"Locke on Property"

by Day, J P (1966)

Abstract

The object of this essay is to examine Locke's justification of private property. But before proceeding to the examination, I have two preliminary points to make about its scope. On the one hand, its scope is wide, for the reason that Locke intends his justification to apply to utilities of all kinds We shall see that Locke's thesis is that every man has a right to own that which he has mixed his labour with; for which reason I call his doctrine his Labour Theory of Property (Sec. 2). Locke's examples of such mixing of labour include making a loaf of bread, picking an apple from a wild apple- tree, and cultivating a piece of hitherto virgin land. The last point calls for special notice. For many writers on property-rights draw a sharp distinction between property in artefacts on the one hand and property in the earth and its natural products on the other, and maintain that private property in these two sorts of utilities requires different justifications. Mill, for instance, agrees with Locke that the foundation of the former property- right is " the right of producers to what they themselves have produced ", but maintains that this principle cannot justify private property in land since "no man made the land ". By contrast, Locke contends that this principle does justify private property in land as well as in artefacts because working land is just one way of mixing labour with something. Hence, "As much land as a man tills, plants, improves, cultivates, and can use the product of, so much is his property. He by his labour does as it were enclose it from the common."'

Keywords

Locke, Property, History Of Ideas, Theory Of Labor, Seventeenth Century

Themes

On Locke

Links to Reference

• http://www.jstor.org/stable/2218464
• http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2218464
• https://www.jstor.org/stable/2218464?casa_token=ufmhh7djM7sAAAAA:r9dIK-Edpo75vLIXWKEVsQdFsqtpr7RY2FmsHvSUttG88L5-O1g9G52Au_F2PnDKOMpLKX_F8Ee9dWEmKXY7vwbByk80M4nwzj-Zy2oJI8NFq6q2LbyE
• https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/2218464.pdf?casa_token=8GfpQ90m4VcAAAAA:G_SABcyhvanuy-CbaVz_QF8XFLbJyTjjMVox_yP7sUQ-pwWLN5LaeSqfNwgrEfno5871E4-u9lWtYSp2mE-U3cVf5lxsgHJIMUJg0LXMePiMN7zc5vre

Citation

Share

How to contribute.